Agatha Christie's legacy looms large in the world of mystery storytelling, but did you know her influence extends far beyond her own novels? From period dramas to postmodern twists, Christie's fingerprints are all over television, even in shows you might not expect. Here's a deep dive into 10 captivating mystery series that will delight fans of the Queen of Crime, each offering a unique spin on the genre she mastered.
But here's where it gets controversial: While Christie's adaptations are beloved, some argue that modern interpretations stray too far from her original vision. Do these shows honor her legacy, or do they take creative liberties that Christie herself might not have approved of? Let’s explore and you decide.
1. Murder, She Wrote (CBS)
Imagine a small-town mystery novelist who stumbles into real-life murder cases—sounds like Christie's Miss Marple, right? Angela Lansbury's Jessica Fletcher is the American counterpart, solving crimes with wit and wisdom. Fun fact: Lansbury played Miss Marple before landing this iconic role. While Hollywood teases a modern reboot, the original remains a timeless classic. And this is the part most people miss: Jessica's move to New York City mid-series shifts the tone, offering a fresh urban twist to her rural roots.
2. Jonathan Creek (BBC)
What happens when a stage magician's consultant turns detective? Alan Davies brings Jonathan Creek to life, using his knowledge of illusions to debunk supernatural mysteries. Paired with the sharp-witted Maddy Magellan, Creek’s accidental heroism echoes Christie’s protagonists. Bold claim: This show blends mystery with magic better than any other on this list. What do you think—does it strike the right balance?
3. Foyle's War (ITV)
Set against the backdrop of WWII, this series follows Superintendent Christopher Foyle, a detective whose unassuming demeanor masks a brilliant mind. Written by Christie alum Anthony Horowitz, Foyle's War feels like a wartime Miss Marple tale. Controversial question: Does the war setting overshadow the mysteries, or does it enhance them?
4. Vera (ITV)
Brenda Blethyn’s Vera Stanhope is a detective on the brink of retirement, but her observational skills keep her in the game. With 14 seasons, Vera is a marathon of British crime-solving. Teaser: The show’s longevity is impressive, but does it ever feel repetitive? Weigh in below.
5. Death in Paradise (BBC/Red Planet)
Sun, sand, and murder—this Caribbean-set series is Christie’s exotic getaways reimagined. With a rotating cast of detectives, Death in Paradise keeps things fresh and funny. Bold interpretation: Is this show a breezy escape or a watered-down take on British crime drama?
6. Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries (ABC)
Phryne Fisher, a 1920s Australian detective, solves crimes with glamour and grit. Essie Davis shines in this period piece that celebrates the Jazz Age without getting lost in historical details. Thought-provoking question: Does the show’s focus on style overshadow its substance?
7. Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators (BBC)
Set in Stratford-upon-Avon, this comedic mystery series pairs a struggling detective with a grieving widow-turned-partner. The low-stakes mysteries are perfect for a cozy watch. Counterpoint: Is the show too lighthearted to be taken seriously as a mystery series?
8. Ms. Ma, Nemesis (SBS TV)
This South Korean adaptation of Christie’s Nemesis modernizes the story with a personal vendetta. Ma Ji-won, a falsely accused mother, escapes prison to solve her daughter’s murder. Controversial take: Is this K-drama a brilliant reinvention or a departure too far from Christie’s original?
9. Poker Face (Peacock)
Rian Johnson’s homage to Christie stars Natasha Lyonne as Charlie Cale, a lie-detecting drifter. Season 2 fixes the pacing issues of its debut, making it a must-watch. Bold question: Is Charlie Cale the modern Miss Marple? Share your thoughts!
10. Magpie Murders (BBC)
A postmodern mystery within a mystery, this series follows a book editor unraveling a real-life crime while piecing together a detective’s final novel. Teaser: Does the dual narrative enhance the story, or does it complicate it unnecessarily?
From classic whodunits to innovative twists, these shows prove Christie’s influence is alive and well. Which one will you binge first? And which do you think Christie herself would have enjoyed? Let the debate begin!
